The short answer
Weld the structure first, then finish-machine datums, fits, and tight features, when those machined surfaces have to sit in the right place after the weld has shrunk and pulled. Machine the parts complete first, then weld, only when the weld is a light attachment that does not control those already-finished faces — a tab, a cover, or a secondary bracket — and can be kept far enough away that typical shrinkage will not take them out of tolerance. A common middle path is to weld first, stress-relieve the weldment when the material and section call for it, and then machine stock left on datums, bores, and mating faces. Name that sequence on the PDF you upload with the STEP through quote-new.php. Do not write “weld and machine as required.”
This is a sequence question, not a weld-spec question
This note is about order: weld then machine, machine then weld, or a split with stock. It is not a weld-procedure specification, and it is not a decision about whether the part should be a weldment at all. If two machined pieces fastened or pinned together would be cleaner, see when should I split a CNC part into two pieces. Quench-and-temper heat treat, an SLM build, and stress relief of a fully machined aluminum plate with no weld are separate calls (see when to specify heat treat after CNC, heat treating steel after CNC machining, SLM residual stress and warpage notes for buyers, and when to specify stress relief after CNC aluminum). Once the part is a weldment, the question is when the machining is done.
A weld shrinks as it cools. A long fillet on one side of a plate will typically bow that plate; a heavy joint next to a bore will typically pull that bore. The amount is not a published constant — it depends on the process, the heat input, the fixture, the section, and the material. If the print already asks for a tight position, a bearing seat, a dowel pattern, or a flat sealing face, plan the finishing cut after that movement has happened.
A weld symbol without a sequence is a guess. A finished bore next to a heavy weld, with no stock and no stress-relief note, does not tell the shop whether to machine the bore first and hope, or to leave stock and finish it after the weld has cooled.
When welding first, then finish machining, is the default
Frames, boxes, and parts whose datums live on the weldment
Weld first when the machined features are defined on the welded structure: a baseplate with welded ribs and a machined mounting face, a box with a bored bearing seat, or a frame with a dowel pattern that must match a mating plate. Those faces and holes only mean something after the members are joined. Typical practice is to weld the members with stock on every surface that will later be a datum or a fit, then machine that stock away.
Tight position, flatness, or a fit that cannot absorb weld pull
Finish-machine after welding when you have written a tight position on a hole pattern, a bearing or seal bore, or a flange face that must sit flat after assembly (see flange bolt-circle position notes for CNC housings, bearing-seat notes for CNC housings, and flatness, parallelism and perpendicularity on machined plates and housings). Leaving stock — often a starting 2–3 mm per face on a general steel weldment, more on a long or heavily welded structure, and sometimes less on a small, lightly TIG-welded part — gives the shop metal to true up after movement. Those allowances are starting points for an RFQ, not a promise that every joint will move the same amount.
Carbon steel, stainless, and aluminum weldments
On carbon and low-alloy steel, weld-then-machine is the ordinary default for fabrications that will be finish-machined. Stainless often moves more than a comparable carbon-steel joint; leave enough stock, and say so (see stainless steel 304 vs 316 vs 17-4PH). Aluminum frames, commonly 6061, are often welded and then machined as well, but the heat-affected zone is softer than the parent T6 plate (see 6061 vs 7075 aluminum). If the mating face or a tapped hole sits in the HAZ, say so, or move the feature.
When machining first, then welding, can work
Light attachments that do not control the datums
Machine first when the finished part is already a complete machined component and the weld is only adding a light tab, a lifting eye, or a secondary bracket that does not establish the primary datums or the tight fits. The shop can finish the main part, then weld the addition in a fixture that protects those faces, but only if typical shrinkage will not take them out of tolerance.
Already-finished threads, seats, and sealing faces
Do not weld next to an already-finished thread, bearing seat, or sealing face and assume the size will hold. If a late weld is unavoidable, protect or remachine those features, or redesign the attachment as a bolted joint. The same sequence thinking applies as in should I cut threads before or after heat treat: a finished precision feature does not belong upstream of a process that moves metal.
Prototypes versus the production routing
On a first article that is only proving envelope, you can sometimes machine pieces complete and weld them with little stock, even if production will use a welded structure with stock and a stress-relief step (see prototype vs production CNC quotes). Put the production sequence on the revision that will actually be built that way; a fully machined prototype does not authorize a silent change.
The hybrid: weld, stress-relieve when needed, then machine stock
The most quotable production path for a steel weldment with tight machined features is usually: cut or machine the members with stock; weld; straighten if you have actually specified it; stress-relieve when the section and the tolerance call for it; then finish-machine the stock.
Post-weld stress relief is not a quench-and-temper heat treat. It is a lower-temperature soak used to reduce residual stress so the part moves less when metal is later cut away. It is often specified on carbon-steel weldments that must hold tight flatness, position, or a bore after finish machining, especially on heavier sections or one-sided welds. A typical starting band for carbon steel is often around 550–650 °C (about 1020–1200 °F); that is a starting process window, not a cycle to invent on the RFQ without naming the grade. Stainless and aluminum do not use that same band. If a relief cycle is in the routing, it belongs before the finishing cuts, not after the part is already finished to a tight size. Shot peening is not a substitute (see when to specify shot peening after CNC steel parts).
Show stock on the members, not only in a general note: thicker datum plates, preparation holes for bores finished after welding, and a clear list of which faces are finished after the joint. Balanced welds and fixturing help, but they do not replace stock on a tight feature. If a later hardening heat treat is also required, treat it as a separate step with its own stock and sequence. Do not bury a quench inside a “weld and machine” note.
Inspection and callouts that make the sequence quotable
Inspect the weld and the machined features as two related but different checks. State weld quality — visual, and dye-penetrant or magnetic-particle inspection when you have actually specified it — as a weld requirement (see when to specify dye-penetrant after CNC, and when to specify MPI after CNC steel). Check machined datums, bores, and patterns after the finishing cuts, often on a CMM when the position is tight (see CMM vs optical measurement for machined parts, and first article inspection). Confirm that stock is still present after welding and after any stress relief, before the finish pass starts.
On the PDF that accompanies the STEP, write a sequence, not a hope:
- Material and grade for each member, and filler if it matters
- Weld process and symbols, or a clear flag that the weld procedure is given on a separate specification
- Sequence: weld first then finish-machine, machine first then weld, or weld, stress-relieve, then machine stock
- Which faces, bores, and hole patterns are finished after welding, and the stock left on each
- Whether a post-weld stress-relief cycle is required, and that it occurs before the finishing cuts
- Any later heat-treat or coating step, and whether size or class applies before or after
- Weld inspection and machined-feature inspection as separate requirements
- A drawing PDF that matches the STEP, uploaded together through quote-new.php
What files to send for a CNC quote and the DFM checklist before an online CNC quote still apply. ISO 2768 general tolerances do not replace a position tolerance on a post-weld hole pattern, and they do not define weld quality.
Mistakes that show up at the CMM
The most common error is a tight bearing bore or dowel pattern drawn on a weldment with no stock and no sequence, so one shop quotes a fully machined part that is later welded and goes out of position, and another quotes stock and a finish pass. The second is a post-weld stress-relief note applied after the finishing cuts. The third is welding a light tab onto an already-finished sealing face or thread with no protection and no remachine allowance. The fourth is calling a carbon-steel stress-relief band on an aluminum or stainless weldment. The fifth is inspecting only the weld, or only the machined size, but not confirming stock before the finish pass. The sixth is changing the production sequence after a fully machined prototype without a revision. A weld symbol is not a machining sequence.
A last look at the files
On quote-new.php, check that each of these is visible on the drawing:
- Weld-then-machine, machine-then-weld, or the hybrid with stock and any stress relief
- Stock on every face, bore, or pattern finished after welding
- Stress-relief cycle before finish machining, or a clear “no stress relief”
- Weld inspection and machined-feature inspection as separate notes
- The PDF and the STEP agree
What drives CNC machining cost and what affects CNC machining lead time both move when you add welding, a furnace stress-relief, extra stock, and a second machining setup, so name those steps on the first RFQ. If the files show the sequence, upload them through quote-new.php and ask for a quote with that weld-and-machine routing, not as a “weld and machine as required” note.
